Word on the Street: Belleville| Brighton | Cobourg | Kingston | Napanee | Peterborough | Prince Edward | Oshawa | Port Hope | Quinte West
Help us advocate for you. Please follow, share and like our content.
If you don’t read the whole thing… here’s the short of it:
Prince Edward County has developed a bad habit: hiring consultants to do the thinking, contractors to do the work, and communications firms to explain why.
Over the past decade, the County’s spending on “contracted services” has nearly doubled — from $11 million in 2015 to more than $20 million in 2025.
By contrast, municipalities like Belleville and Quinte West have kept outside contracting flat or tied to capital projects. Instead of building in-house expertise, Prince Edward County has built dependency — and taxpayers are footing the bill.
The Rise of the Consultant Economy
Everywhere you look, there’s a report. A planning review here, a housing strategy there, a “comprehensive modernization study” collecting dust on a shelf.
Each year, Shire Hall commissions dozens of studies, plans, and frameworks — many of them revisiting issues that have already been studied.
The cost is staggering.
County budget data show that spending on contracted services and consultants climbed from $11 million in 2014 to $20.3 million in 2024, an 84% increase in ten years.
That’s faster than growth in wages, inflation, or population — and far faster than the County’s capacity to implement the advice it pays for.
What Other Municipalities Spend
To see how far out of line the County has drifted, consider the benchmarks:
| Municipality | Population | 2024 Contracted Services ($M) | % of Total Budget | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prince Edward County | 27,300 | $20.3M | 23% | High reliance on external firms |
| Belleville | 56,000 | $22.5M | 12% | Focused on capital and engineering contracts |
| Quinte West | 45,000 | $18.0M | 10% | Heavy use of in-house staff for planning and finance |
| Cobourg | 20,500 | $8.1M | 11% | Outsources select IT and legal only |
(Source: 2024 municipal operating budgets and staff reports)
Prince Edward County stands out — and not in a good way.
While other municipalities use consultants for specialized expertise or capital projects, the County increasingly outsources routine governance functions: HR policy, communications strategy, planning rationales, grant writing, and even community consultations.
How We Got Here
Three things explain this dependence:
- Institutional turnover.
Frequent senior-staff departures have created gaps in institutional memory. Consultants are used to “bridge the transition” — but the bridges never end. - Risk aversion.
By hiring consultants, staff can point to an external report when decisions backfire. Accountability is outsourced along with the work. - Culture of deference.
Councillors often lack the technical expertise or confidence to challenge consultants’ conclusions. Reports are received, filed, and forgotten — until the next one is commissioned.
The Hidden Cost
Hiring consultants doesn’t just cost money — it delays decisions.
Each new study requires RFPs, procurement cycles, and months of review.
By the time the report lands, the circumstances have often changed.
Meanwhile, residents wait — for a housing strategy, a tourism plan, a water capacity update, or zoning reform that never seems to arrive.
The County’s 2023 “Comprehensive Service Review,” for instance, cost more than $300,000 and promised to identify operational efficiencies.
Two years later, few of its recommendations have been implemented — and a follow-up study is already being discussed.
That’s not modernization. That’s motion without progress.
What Other Municipalities Do Differently
Belleville:
Runs most strategic work in-house. The city’s Planning and Engineering departments produce studies internally, allowing council to act quickly and cheaply. The city occasionally hires third parties for environmental assessments or complex capital design, but never for basic operations or HR.
Quinte West:
Uses a “build knowledge once” approach — when a consultant is hired for a project, internal staff are required to shadow and absorb the expertise. It’s professional development by design, reducing the need for repeat engagements.
Cobourg:
Limits external contracts to specialized technical work (IT, legal, audit). Staff are expected to write all policy documents and manage communication themselves — fostering accountability and pride of ownership.
The County’s Dependency Problem
Prince Edward County has built a system where consultants outlast councillors.
Reports pile up, and many of the same firms return every few years to update their own work.
Residents joke that “consultant” has become the County’s largest employer.
This dependency weakens public trust.
When every policy is authored by an outside firm, who, exactly, is running the County?
A Smarter Way Forward
- Establish a Consultant Audit.
Publish an annual summary of all third-party contracts, including cost, scope, and deliverables. Residents deserve to know what they’re paying for — and whether they got it. - Build Internal Capacity.
Create a permanent Policy & Strategy Division to reduce external reliance. Recruit planners, analysts, and engineers capable of preparing studies in-house. - Mandate Knowledge Transfer.
Every consultant hired must train staff before final payment is released. That way, expertise stays within Shire Hall. - Cap Consulting Expenditures.
Limit external contracts to 10% of the total operating budget, in line with Belleville and Quinte West averages. - Hold Departments Accountable.
Department heads should justify why internal staff couldn’t perform the work before outsourcing.
Council’s Responsibility
Ultimately, this isn’t a staff problem — it’s a Council failure of oversight.
Elected officials must stop approving blank-cheque RFPs for every policy issue and start demanding results from their own departments.
True leadership means owning decisions, not delegating them.
It means building expertise inside the organization, not renting it year after year.
Until that happens, the County will keep paying consultants to tell it what it already knows:
that inefficiency, duplication, and indecision are costing residents millions.
Conclusion: Reclaim the County’s Competence
Prince Edward County doesn’t lack intelligence or talent.
It lacks confidence — the belief that its own people can think, plan, and execute without a consultant at the table.
The solution isn’t another review.
It’s the courage to do the work ourselves.
Stop outsourcing. Start governing.
Word on the Street: Belleville| Brighton | Cobourg | Kingston | Napanee | Peterborough | Prince Edward | Oshawa | Port Hope | Quinte West
Help us advocate for you. Please follow, share and like our content.